Reading Time: 2 minutes

Move over, Batman.

There’s a new comeback story in town, and it’s about as dramatic as a Snyder Cut reveal. Mattel has successfully clawed back the lucrative rights to make DC-themed action figures and other toys, wresting them from the hands of competitor Spin Master. It’s like watching a classic superhero arc—Mattel, once the undisputed king of molded plastic heroes, fell into the shadows, trained in the art of strategic licensing deals, and has now returned, battle-scarred but victorious, to reclaim its throne.

The Toy Industry’s Version of a Multiverse Reset

For those who don’t religiously track the tectonic shifts in the toy industry (and let’s be honest, most of us just want to buy cool figures without thinking too hard), here’s the quick backstory: Mattel lost the rights to produce DC action figures back in 2019. The license went to Spin Master, and suddenly, the company best known for Paw Patrol was in charge of crafting Gotham’s finest. To put it in comic book terms, it was as if Aquaman had taken over the Batcave—functional, but a little odd.

But now? Mattel’s back, baby! And it’s not just getting its hands on Batman and Superman again—it’s securing exclusive rights for DC action figures, playsets, and vehicles. Think Batmobiles, Kryptonian crystal fortresses, and whatever weird gadget Lex Luthor has cooked up this time.

The Business of Playtime: It’s a Ruthless Game

Mattel’s win is no accident. With its ongoing success with Barbie (cue an Oscar-worthy Greta Gerwig adaptation) and the monster profits from Hot Wheels and Masters of the Universe, the toy giant is flexing harder than a freshly sculpted six-inch Superman figure. The return of DC to Mattel’s lineup means it can integrate these characters into its finely tuned production machine, which is good news for collectors, kids, and anyone who’s ever impulse-bought a Batman figure at Target.

And let’s not forget, Mattel isn’t just playing around (pun absolutely intended). This win ensures a stronghold on nostalgia-driven markets and the ever-expanding world of adult collectors. Yes, adults. Because why spend your money on boring things like mortgages and savings accounts when you can finally own a hyper-detailed, limited-edition, glow-in-the-dark, alternate-universe Batman?

Spin Master: The Unexpected Villain?

Spin Master, of course, is playing it cool. They still have other licensing deals, and their exit statement reads like a diplomatic press release rather than a villainous monologue. But let’s be real: losing DC toys stings. No one wants to be the studio that used to have the rights to Batman (cough Warner Bros. with Christopher Nolan cough). The transition back to Mattel will take place in 2026, which means Spin Master has some time to savor its final days of Gotham stewardship—before Mattel sweeps back in like an inevitable Justice League reboot.

The Real Winners? Collectors and Kids (and Maybe Mattel’s Stockholders)

For fans, this is a win. Mattel’s past DC figures had a certain heft, quality, and articulation that made them stand out, and with today’s technology, expect even better versions of your favorite superheroes. As for parents, well, brace yourselves—because these toys will be everywhere.

So, what’s next for Mattel? Maybe a bold move to take over Star Wars figures? A secret plot to absorb Marvel? Who knows. But one thing’s for sure: in the endless cycle of licensing deals and corporate battles, the biggest hero is always the one holding the rights to the Bat-Signal.

Until then, keep your shelves ready. The action figure wars are just beginning.

Author(s)

This content is not intended to provide legal advice or opinion as neither can be given without reference to specific events and situations. © 2021 Nelligan O’Brien Payne LLP.

Have Questions?

Enjoy this article?
Don’t forget to share.

Related Posts

Intellectual Property Law
Blog
Reading time: 3 mins
As a trademark agent, I have seen some colourful branding disputes. The most recent – a showdown between Buc-ee’s—the Texas-based[...]
Intellectual Property Law
Blog
Reading time: 3 mins
In a gloriously chaotic trademark case, Lady Gaga is being sued for $100 million over the word Mayhem. Not by[...]
Intellectual Property Law
Blog
Reading time: 3 mins
The world is mourning the loss of George Foreman—a titan of sport, an icon of resilience, and a man whose[...]